The initiative is an effort to affect the growing problem of obesity.
|Labour's Diane Abbott is declaring|
war on everyone else's fat.
Technically it's a tax.
Effectively it's a penalty.
Traditionally government greed has chosen fines as the method of choice to penalize people who fail to follow the straight and narrow.
So what makes a penalty a tax?
In the fizzy-drink scenario, the penalty is applied every time anyone purchases a soda; unlike a traffic fine that is levied only when a person is caught violating the law.
Because the fine is a universally-applied penalty, it is technically a tax. At least that's the way the U.S. Supreme Court seems to interpret it.
ObamaCare's mandate is, like the fizzy drink penalty, considered a tax.
There is no arrest warrant. There is no court hearing. There is no recourse. There is no jury of peers. There is no plea bargaining.
There is only presumption of guilt.
It's like being dunned by a tax agency. You're presumed guilty.
The ObamaCare penalty is designed to punish those who fail to purchase health insurance. Because it is punitive, its purpose is to modify behavior through the intimidation and imminent pain of financial loss.
Two concerns arise:
First is the precedent. If a punitive penalty can be applied to ObamaCare (or fizzy drinks in Britain), it can be applied to any predictable behavior.
I don't expect the government to impose a TV tax for sets that log more than 10 hours per week. I can, however, imagine a excessive fuel tax on vehicles that exceed a predetermined number of gallons of gasoline purchased per month.
Second is the increase. Think of a tax that has not increased. Those who have the authority to raise taxes also have personal and philosophical agendas that require funding. Expect the ObamaCare penalty tax to increase. Expect he soda tax, if imposed, to increase.
Don't expect the Labour Party to suggest a tax credit when consumers purchase Gatorade.
Like this story?
Help Kenn spread the word by clicking it onto Facebook. See icon below . . .
Permission is granted to use the material in this article providing (1) the byline is included in an obvious manner crediting DailyKenn.com as the author, (2) a link to this page is included and (3) no changes are made either by deletion, addition or annotation. Original compositions at DailyKenn.com are sometimes seeded with decoy data, such as hidden acronyms, to detect unauthorized use and plagiarism.
COMMENTS: The use of vulgarities and pejoratives may result in your comment being zapped.